School portraits / One evening with the November 2023 inspection report
Vast/Overwhelming Majority or Almost All
Doha College’s 2023 inspection report defines its words before it judges anyone. I made the mistake of taking the definitions home.
Before the Doha College inspection report says a single word about the school, it tells you what its words mean. Ninety to 100 per cent is “Vast/overwhelming majority or almost all”. Seventy-five to 90 is “most”. Nought to three per cent is “Almost none/very few”. I lived in Doha for two years, went to eleven coffee mornings, and nobody once told me where “most” started.
I applied the key to our household that evening, on the back of a DHL envelope. Mornings we leave the house on time: small minority. The middle one’s sentences that concern Minecraft: vast/overwhelming majority. Contents of the shipping crate labelled MISC — KITCHEN? seen since it was packed in Houston: almost none/very few, and an inspector would make me write none.
Then I read the rest, cover to cover, standing up. Four inspectors from Education Development Trust. Four days in November 2023. The dates were agreed with ten weeks’ notice, which is nine weeks and six days more than my mother-in-law gives. They observed 75 part-lessons, attended four assemblies and held 46 meetings.
Forty-six. I have had one meeting with my husband about a sofa, and it lasted until we moved.
The subject: a school that opened in 1980 and now has 2,604 pupils from 83 nationalities. In 2020 it merged three schools on two sites into a single campus at Al Wajba. We have never successfully merged two sock drawers. And then the line that made me get up and walk round the kitchen: “Pupils settle quickly to work as soon as they enter the classroom and remain focused throughout the lesson.” The middle one enters our kitchen and remains focused on the fridge.
It kept escalating. Year 9 pupils had combined physics, technology and maths to study traffic management in cities, and established that the speed of vehicles is determined by force and distance. Two years on the roads of Doha, and I had established only that the speed of vehicles is determined by whether I am late. Everyone on site, parents included, must wear the appropriate lanyard, and the security team checks them robustly. I own lanyards from six schools. Not one has ever been robustly checked. I would have wept with gratitude.
So I went looking for the villain. More than twenty pages; there had to be one. There was. In a small number of lessons, the inspectors found, formative assessment was not always used consistently, and they recommended more training on assessment and data. That was the whole dark secret. Ours is in a crate.
I wrote our report on the other side of the envelope. Overall effectiveness: satisfactory. Notice given: none. Development point: open the crate. Proportion of the household that agreed to be inspected: almost none/very few.
Me. I was also the inspector.
Sources
People and scenes in the column may be invented; the school facts come from these published sources.
- Entry requirements — assessments, sixth form bar and waiting lists dohacollege.com
- Doha College CAT4 entry guide — entry-year rules and 2024 results summary pretestplus.co.uk
- Fees — 2026-2027 schedule, capital charge and joining fees dohacollege.com
- Connect & Visit — Al Wajba campus location dohacollege.com
- Doha College BSO inspection report, 5–8 November 2023 (Education Development Trust) edtlive.b-cdn.net